At some time next month I will offer you my usual annual reflections on this Supreme Court term. I make this note in advance, about a case SCOTUS has decided NOT to hear. On June 21, the Supreme Court declined to take up the case of MONSANTO v. HARDEMAN. In this matter a Californian man named Edwin Hardeman alleged RoundUp, a Monsanto product, had caused his cancer. Hardeman received an award from a federal district court, applying California state law, of $25 million after a jury trial. But Monsanto has appealed, claiming that the matter is preempted by federal law, and the US EPA has concluded that the herbicide does not pose "any reasonable risk to man or the environment." Monsanto appealed, and the 9th Circuit held for plaintiff. The US, under Trump, sought to intervene and take Monsanto's side before SCOTUS. The government, under Biden, has indicated that it takes Hardeman's view and wants the award to stand. SCOTUS has decided not to hear ...