Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label shaving cream

Back to the Monty Hall problem

Last time I started out talking about this, I was sidetracked. I'll try again. You are on a game show. There are three doors. Behind two of the doors one would find a worthless gag gift. A pile of shaving cream or whatever. Behind the third door, a big check for a million dollars. You pick door 1, aware that the probability of getting the $1 million by virtue of this choice is 1/3. The game show host ("Monty Hall" for us oldsters), says, "Ah, that might be right or might be wrong. I'm gonna give you a clue and open door number 2." Door 2 opens. You see a pile of shaving cream. Everyone laughs because by convention the sight of a useless 'gift' is funny. Monty renews the choice. Now narrowed down a bit. You can stick with your initial decision, Door 1, or you can go with Door 3. What do you do and why? The striking answer is that if you are a rational being you will switch to door number 3 at this point. Your odds of being right wit...