Skip to main content

Posts

A Critique of Pure Knowledge of Clouds

  Judy Collins (or rather Joni Mitchell) seems to have given us a very Kantian discussion of Clouds, in the song "Both Sides, Now".   That first verse leads to the conclusion that we never really know clouds at all.  We only know them from our various phenomenal perspectives, from "up and down". As it happens a cloud is the ideal "object" for making this Kantian point from CRITIQUE OF PURE REASON.  For whatever we mean by "object" in common parlance, sometimes it isn't an object at all.  From the inside, it's just a foggy day. So clouds are clearly not things-in-themselves, say the cantatrices. Then there is looking at ... love. Again, Joni and Judy see it from two sides, "the dizzy dancing way you feel" on the one hand, and "just another show" on the other. She, and we, don't know love at all.  From Kant, there is the "incentives" chapter in the CRITIQUE OF PRACTICAL REASON.  He writes in this chapter of...
Recent posts

Quoting from LOMBARD STREET

Something I've learned from Bagehot. And now I'm amazed that I got this far in life with the interests that I've had, and have NOT known it.  It appears that the England left the gold standard in 1797. In time the powers-that-be reverted to it. But in the face of an expensive war with a continental foe (the year began after all with Napoleon's victory at the battle of Rivoli), the Privy Council ordered the Bank of England to stop converting banknotes into gold. Later in the year Parliament confirmed this order with a law. The Bank complied.  Those notes continued to circulate. Furthermore, they seem to have retained the same value for years.  The Brits didn't return to the gold standard until about thirty years later.  Troubles had appeared by 1810 that foretold that end.  Yet during those first thirteen years of the fiat money experiment -- it seemed to go swimmingly, as Bagehot tells it. "There was no check, these notes could not come back to the Bank for pay...

An Adam Smith quote about ... math?

  Adam Smith, in THEORY OF MORAL SENTIMENTS, says the following about math (in the context of a discussion of why utility alone is not the foundation of moral sentiments): "...it has been observed on a former occasion, that superior reason and understanding are originally approved of as just and right and accurate, and not merely as useful or advantageous. It is in the abstruser sciences, particularly in the higher parts of mathematics, that the greatest and most admired exertions of human reason have been displayed. But the utility of those sciences, either to the individual or to the public, is not very obvious, and to prove it requires a discussion which is not always very easily comprehended. It was not, therefore, their utility which first recommended them to the public admiration. This quality was but little insisted upon, till it became necessary to make some reply to the reproaches of those, who, having themselves no taste for such sublime discoveries, endeavoured to depre...

Six years ago

"Welcome back" "Thank you.  It is good to be back."  Six years ago now the news was full of facts and arguments about the number of Republican Senators and Representatives who might object to the certification of the election of Joseph Biden. The background to this was an intra-party fight.  Many Republicans were inwardly writing off Trump and the Trump era already. They were maneuvering over who would be the Big Cheese in the post-Trump Republican Party that they happily expected President Biden's term would initiate.  The majority leader, Senator McConnell, broke openly with Trump in this period, for example by arranging the override of his veto on the defense appropriations bill (without even trying to do anything about the social media immunity that Trump wanted to tie this to) and by McConnell's refusal even to let people vote on the President’s desire to send out a lot of $2,000 checks. They were sick of each other. I bring these acts up because they t...

Taking a week off

  Our editorial staff is taking a week off from posting on this site. See you next week. So, you may ask, why that photo?  Oh, and did you hear about the religious cult that worships a particular shade of blue? Cyan - tology. 

The midterms and data centers

There is a whole lot that one might say about Tuesday's midterm elections . Let's see if I can come up with something more novel than most of the early coverage. My question is -- what if anything does the "blue wave" of Democratic victories tell us about the future creation of data centers, with their developmental and environmental costs and accordingly about the continued development of artificial intelligence in the United States?  In the Governor's race in Texas, Gina Hinojosa successfully made the unchecked expansion of data centers a central part of her campaign against Greg Abbott. She advocates a moratorium, and work toward stronger protections for electric and water utility rate payers.  This race was not alone in elevating data centers from a local development issue to a state-wide issue.  But since it involves TEXAS, this race clearly suggests it has a future as a national issue, if Hinojosa herself can become an Ann Richards sized figure.  The Ohio Se...

Plato: metaphysics and ethics

Gee, I thought this was obvious.  Why does it require elaborate argument at this point, millennia out?  What am I talking/asking about?  A new book by Lloyd P. Gerson called PLATO'S MORAL REALISM. Reviewed here: Plato's Moral Realism | Reviews | Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews | University of Notre Dame    Gerson is affiliated with the University of Toronto and is a fellow in the Royal Society of Canada.  "Moral realism" in the title's usage includes any view to the effect that good and evil, right or wrong, are objective facts, independent of our perception of them, open both to knowledge and to reasoned discourse about that knowledge NOT subjective matters of opinion or emotive expressions like "boooo" or "yippee!" or anything of the sort. The NDPR review of Gerson's book paraphrases his key points this way, "Plato is a metaethical non-naturalist realist, and we isolate his normative theory from his metaphysics are our interpretiv...